In this debate, I went head to head with Tony over the MAGA freakout about Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl halftime show, and what it actually says about the state of the right. My basic point was simple. Bad Bunny waved the American flag, said “God bless America,” and put up a banner that read “love is stronger than hate.” If that is considered anti-American now, then we seriously need to recalibrate. Conservatives lost their minds because he performed in Spanish and acknowledged Latin American identity, which in a country with tens of millions of Spanish speakers is not radical. It is reality. Tony argued it was politically performative and out of place. I argued that criticizing the government and representing your culture is about as American as it gets.
But the conversation did not stay on pop culture for long. It turned into a much more heated clash about Trump, leadership, and whether both sides are equally responsible for the toxicity in our politics. I brought up birtherism, the Rob Reiner comment, the AI gorilla post, and the constant top down outrage that defines Trump’s brand. Tony tried to frame Trump as a product of the times. I pushed back and said leadership actually matters, especially for people my age who want something better than nonstop chaos. What started as a debate about a halftime show became a much bigger argument about accountability and whether the president of the United States should be raising the bar or dragging it into the mud.
If you appreciate my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber. Thank you!
